BACK TO SCHOOL WITHOUT SUPPLIES: Local single-parent families struggle as Child Tax Benefit clawed back
MP Marston asks new Revenue Canada Minister to end the claw-back
Ottawa – In an open letter to the new Minister of Revenue Gordon O’Connor, Hamilton East – Stoney Creek MP Wayne Marston demanded that Harper’s government stop the claw-back and withholding of single-parent Child Tax Benefit.
“This week alone 3 single-parents, all women, came for assistance in my Hamilton office because Minister O’Connor’s department told them that they will have to pay back the Government thousands of dollars they received from the Child Tax Benefit. What was the reason the Department gave? Although they believe the parent with the children claiming the CTB lives alone, that apparently doesn’t equate to knowing that the other parent doesn’t live with them.” Marston added that “It is preposterous double-speak that means families in our community are suffering and parents have to add school supplies to the list of basic household items they cannot afford.”
Single-parents raising children must prove their marital status including living arrangements in order to be eligible for the single-parent tax benefit. Proving marital status and living arrangements is often difficult and can be demeaning to have one’s private life on display, as it can require going back several years and finding 3 separate individuals who can attest to their living situations.
“I asked the former Minister to look into this situation back in June and was told they do “no such thing” yet more women in my community are seeking assistance again as they receive threatening letters from CRA telling them they owe thousands of dollars. I’m hopeful the new Minister will have more to say and actually fix this problem” commented Marston.
“All single-parents should have access to programs, like the Child Tax Benefit, that are designed to assist them provide the basics to their children without having to jump through hoops.”
-30-
OPEN LETTER TO MINISTER O'CONNOR
August 30th 2007
OPEN LETTER TO
The Hon. Gordon O’Connor
Minister of National Revenue
Via fax: 613-992-1043 (original to follow)
Dear Minister O’Connor,
First, please allow me to congratulate you on your new position as Minister of National Revenue. Ordinary Canadians will be looking to you and your Department for fair revenue policies that are designed to assist working families as they contribute to the economic prosperity of our nation.
I am writing today about a situation regarding the Child Tax Benefit that I raised with your predecessor in the House of Commons in June. Unfortunately, many single-parent families in my constituency of Hamilton East – Stoney Creek, mostly women headed households have approached me about the financial difficulty that they are in as a result of the clawback and withholding of the Child Tax Benefit.
In all the cases, these women headed households are being asked to prove their living arrangements i.e. that the parent of their child or children no longer lives with them. Often, women remain in the communal or matrimonial home after a separation or divorce so this can be difficult and your Departments’ approach seems to be to open these women’s lives up going back several years requiring “proof” of living arrangements through testimonials and documentation. But sometimes even that is not enough and these single parents are told they have to pay back money because although the officials believe that they do live alone, they don’t have proof of the other parent(s) living arrangements.
Children and the parents who are providing for them should not suffer because of a lack of insight or flexibility from your Department or because the other parent has not fulfilled their duty to prove that they no longer live in the same household as the child.
My staff has tried to work with CRA staff to resolve these cases, but single parents continue to receive letters demanding thousands of dollars back from the CTB and are regularly told the CTB will be withheld until living arrangement by the other parent are “proved”.
Minister O’Connor there has got to be a better way to provide the assistance these families require to ensure that the children are provided for. Women in my community have had to add school supplies to the list of basic household items that they cannot provide for their children at this time.
I look forward to your speedy response on these issues and would welcome another opportunity to speak about the particular cases that I have raised so that these families are provided with the benefit to which Canadians believe they are entitled.
It is time to fix this problem and ensure that the Child Tax Benefit is not clawed-back or withheld from hard-working families and the children who it is designed to help.
Yours truly,
(original signed by Wayne Marston)
Wayne Marston, MP
Hamilton East – Stoney Creek
NDP Advocate for Human Rights, Multiculturalism and Sport